Top Pizza Spots in Westchester
Hunting for that standout slice in Westchester? We’ve tracked down some local legends that have history and flavor combos that’ll keep you coming back for another slice. Let’s break it down to the best pizza spots around.
Oldest Pizzerias in Westchester
Westchester is home to some real pizza veterans, serving slices longer than most of us have been around.
- Roma Restaurant in Tuckahoe: Swinging open its doors back in 1931, Roma Restaurant claims its spot as Westchester’s elder in the pizza game. Known for those crisp, thin-crust pies cooked in a brick oven, this spot has pizza lovers coming home for the taste they’ve loved for generations.
Unique Pizza Styles in Westchester
Westchester is a pizza playground with styles that mix the traditional with the downright creative. Whether you’re team Neapolitan or looking for a slice off the beaten path, here’s what you can find:
| Pizzeria | Where It’s At | Style & Flavor | What Makes It Special |
|---|---|---|---|
| Utica Pie Co. | White Plains | Upstate Mix | Dough-proofed for days |
| Pizzeria La Rosa | New Rochelle | Neapolitan | Uses a 100-year-old oven magic |
| Capriccio | Croton-on-Hudson | Cauliflower Crust | Crunchy, fresh toppings infusion |
- Utica Pie Co. in White Plains: Born from the flavors of upstate NY, this joint mixes elements from Chicago, Detroit, straight up to NY style itself. Their dough takes its sweet time—24 to 36 hours—leading to a unique hearty pie that’ll speak to you.
- Pizzeria La Rosa in New Rochelle: Here, classic Neapolitan pie meets history with its century-old pizza oven. One bite of this takes you on a flavor journey straight to the heart of Italy.
- Capriccio in Croton-on-Hudson: With a thin cauliflower crust, it’s like a salad met a pizza in the best way possible. Topped with a mix of arugula, prosciutto, Parmigiano, cherry tomatoes, and balsamic, it delivers taste and texture perfection.
For even more meal inspiration, peep the best restaurants in Westchester or plan your next brunch in Westchester that’s sure to be a hit.
Best Whole Pie Pizzerias
If you’re all about that whole pizza life, Westchester County has two real stars: Johnny’s Pizzeria in Mount Vernon and Polpettina in Eastchester. These places aren’t messing around—they’re famous for their tasty pizzas and have the accolades to prove it.
Johnny’s Pizzeria in Mount Vernon
Johnny’s Pizzeria in Mount Vernon should be high up on your list for a full pizza pie. According to Westchester Magazine, Johnny’s nails that classic, thin-crust style that screams both flavor and tradition. When you’re on a pizza quest in Westchester, this spot is a definite must-hit.
| Pizza Type | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Cheese Pizza | Mozzarella and tomato sauce, the classic | $15.00 |
| Pepperoni Pizza | Pepperoni party with cheese and sauce | $18.50 |
| Margherita Pizza | Mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, and basil | $19.00 |
Andrew Vitelli has Johnny’s pegged as the top pizza spot in Westchester County in The Examiner News. It’s a must-visit for anyone craving that authentic, top-notch pie.
Polpettina in Eastchester
Now, if you’re looking for something less traditional, Polpettina in Eastchester has you covered. They’re known for their creative twists and artisan flavors, which definitely have people talking.
| Pizza Type | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Bianca | Ricotta, mozzarella, and a garlic kick | $20.00 |
| Truffle Mushroom | Mushrooms and truffle oil on a white base | $22.00 |
| Fig & Pig | Fig jam, prosciutto, and arugula | $24.00 |
Polpettina is all about those special flavor combos and quality taste. When you’re in the mood for a not-so-ordinary pizza experience, this is your spot.
For more tasty bites around town, swing by our pieces on the best restaurants in Westchester and the best brunch in Westchester. If you’re thirsty or after something sweet, check out the best bars in Westchester and the best ice cream in Westchester.
So go treat yourself to Johnny’s and Polpettina—and enjoy a couple of slices of the finest pizza Westchester’s got. Each offers a unique twist on pizza craftsmanship, so you’re guaranteed a memorable slice.
Top Slice Spots
You know that unmistakable aroma, right? When you’re on the hunt for a killer slice in Westchester, two spots that hit it out of the park are Dunwoodie in Yonkers and Gino’s Pizzeria. They’ve got the kind of New York-style pizzas that even the pickiest of eaters can’t help but devour.
Dunwoodie in Yonkers
Dunwoodie is your go-to for that classic triangular piece of cheesy paradise, right in Westchester County’s backyard. I mean, people are practically singing its praises from the rooftops. Seriously, back in 2018, locals voted it the top dog of pizzas in the whole county, according to LoHud.
What keeps folks coming back? It’s all about that crispy, thin crust paired with a perfectly seasoned tomato sauce and just enough melty cheese to tie it all together. And don’t even get me started on how cozy the vibe is in there—it’s like the pizza-loving version of Cheers!
| Pizza Type | Cheese | Pepperoni | Veggie |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price per Slice (USD) | 3.00 | 3.50 | 4.00 |
| Customer Rating (out of 5) | 4.8 | 4.7 | 4.6 |
Gino’s Pizzeria in Yonkers
Roll up to Gino’s Pizzeria and you’ll find yourself spoilt for choice with possibly the best pizza in Westchester. Locals and visitors can’t get enough of the old-school recipes and top-notch ingredients that Gino’s whips out every single day.
Here, variety is key. Whether you’re a classic pepperoni lover or a BBQ chicken aficionado, there’s a slice here with your name on it. They get that balance just right with a thin, crispy crust and toppings that are the stuff of dreams.
| Pizza Type | Cheese | Pepperoni | BBQ Chicken |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price per Slice (USD) | 2.75 | 3.25 | 4.50 |
| Customer Rating (out of 5) | 4.5 | 4.6 | 4.7 |
Both Dunwoodie and Gino’s do pizza the way it’s supposed to be done. They’re staples for anyone who’s all about that perfect slice in Westchester. And while you’re stuffing your face with slices, maybe think about checking out our lists on the best restaurants in Westchester and the best places to eat in Westchester. Go on, treat yourself!
Specialty Pizzas in Westchester
Vegan & Gluten-Free Options
Who says you can’t have your pizza and cater to your dietary needs, too? In Westchester, you’ll find delightful specialty pizzas catering to vegan and gluten-free folks, among others. A top player in this field is Pureganic Café in Harrison, the hotspot for plant-based food lovers. If you’re all about keeping your diet clean, this place has got your back with vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and sugar-free delights. One highlight is their famous vegan organic truffled-mushroom pizza with a made-from-scratch gluten-free crust.
| Venue | Specialty | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Pureganic Café | Organic Truffled-Mushroom Pizza | Vegan, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free |
| Pureganic Café | Customizable Pizza | Ethically sourced, Local Ingredients |
Got a hankering for more local eats? Check out some top cafés in Westchester or scope out the best brunch spots in Westchester for more tasty finds.
Unique Flavor Combinations
Westchester pizza joints are all about mixing it up with flavors that make your taste buds do a happy dance. Take Billy & Pete’s Social in Larchmont, for instance, serving up Detroit-style pizzas that are anything but ordinary. Their Choripan pizza takes a walk on the wild side with pomodoro sauce and chorizo slices, all topped with real-deal Argentinian chimichurri.
Meanwhile, Marcello’s Pizzeria in Pelham flips the script with their Burrata Pie. Toppings like mortadella and creamy burrata, kissed with basil pesto and olive oil, make for a pie that’s pure indulgence. The secret weapon? A wood-fired oven that turns each slice into something unforgettable.
| Venue | Unique Pizza | Notable Ingredients |
|---|---|---|
| Billy & Pete’s Social | Choripan | Pomodoro sauce, Chorizo, Chimichurri |
| Marcello’s Pizzeria | Burrata Pie | Mortadella, Burrata, Basil Pesto, Olive Oil |
Craving more delectable finds? Our guides to the best restaurants in Westchester and the best dinner spots in Westchester have you covered.
Dive into the specialty pizzas and savor the best pies Westchester has to offer, from vegan and gluten-free finds to those with flavors that surprise and delight. Every pizzeria has its own charm, promising a dinner you won’t soon forget. Want to explore more of Westchester’s food scene? Check out our picks for the best steakhouses in Westchester or the best sushi in Westchester.
