Pies in Westchester
Hunting for the top pies in Westchester County is like embarking on a tasty treasure hunt, with local bakers mixing magic into every pie. These culinary heroes have made a name for themselves by appealing to every sweet tooth and savory craving out there.
Culinary Delights
Westchester has the inside scoop when it comes to pies, with bakers turning out some of the juiciest and most flavorful pies in the area. Whether you’re old-fashioned or like a twist, each pie, with its own mix of ingredients, tells a flavorful tale.
| Pie Type | Key Ingredient | Must-Visit Bakeries |
|---|---|---|
| Apple Pie | Apples & Spices | Baked By Susan, Galloway’s Bakery |
| Cherry Pie | Cherries & Sugar | Baked By Susan, Noble Pies |
| Pumpkin Pie | Pumpkin & Spices | Pieconic NY |
| Bourbon Chocolate | Bourbon & Chocolate | Pieconic NY |
| Chicken Pot Pie | Chicken & Vegetables | Noble Pies |
More yummy bites await in our guide to the best pies in Westchester.
Popular Pie Spots
Westchester’s pie parade rolls out with bakeries that blend skill and dedication like an artist with a brush. Check out these must-visit pie heavens:
- Baked By Susan: Nestled in Croton-on-Hudson, this spot is famous for hearty apple pies and cherry pies oozing with goodness. Don’t miss their hand-made empanadas, a local hit.
- Galloway’s Bakery: Open only on weekends in Scarsdale, folks line up for miles to snag their sought-after apple pies, especially as the holiday bells start ringing.
- Enrico’s Pastry Shop: Holding fort in Hartsdale, Enrico’s is where pie meets imagination, offering delightful innovations like the cronut and cragel. Their creativity doesn’t stop at pastries.
Check out where to munch next with Westchester’s best places to eat.
Satisfy your cravings with Westchester’s pie wonders and swing by our feature on the best bakery in Westchester to discover even more tasty indulgences.
Notable Pie Bakeries
How do you find some of the yummiest pies in Westchester? Well, a few bakeries really take the cake (pun intended) for their mouth-watering goodness. Let’s dig into what makes these spots the cream of the crop!
Baked By Susan
Over in Croton-on-Hudson, Baked By Susan keeps locals drooling with its home-style pies that have all-butter crusts. Folks go wild for the sour cherry, pumpkin, mixed berry, and pecan pies (Hudson Valley Magazine). But hey, if you’re more into savory pies, they whip up a mean chicken pot pie and quiches too. It’s a haven for both sweet and savory lovers out there.
| Pie Type | Star Varieties | Extra Treats |
|---|---|---|
| Sweet Pies | Sour Cherry, Pumpkin, Mixed Berry, Pecan | None |
| Savory Pies | Chicken Pot Pie, Quiche | None |
Galloway’s Bakery
You’ve got to check out Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale, open just on weekends, but boy do they make it count! People rave over their apple pie, and during Thanksgiving, it’s like a treasure hunt with long lines stretching out the door. Take Teresa Welsh from Yonkers, she’s known to line up before the morning sun to snag one of these goodies.
| Day | Open Hours | Top Pick |
|---|---|---|
| Saturday | 6:00 AM – 6:00 PM | Apple Pie |
| Sunday | 6:00 AM – 6:00 PM | Apple Pie |
Enrico’s Pastry Shop
Now let’s chat about Enrico’s Pastry Shop in Hartsdale. Joseph Floriano, the baking wizard here, crafts pastry magic with treats you don’t see every day. Ever tried a cronut? It’s a fluffy croissant made round with a sticky glaze and creamy twirl. Or how about a cragel that mixes bagels with croissants? The cinnamon raisin version topped with apple-strudel cream cheese is a game-changer.
| Product | What It’s About | Flavors & More Stuff |
|---|---|---|
| Cronut | Croissant-like round with sticky glaze and swirl of cream | – |
| Cragel | Mix of bagel and croissant happiness | Cinnamon Raisin with Apple-Strudel Cream |
Hankering for more tasty spots? Check out our guide to the best bakeries in Westchester and dive into the world of baked brilliance in town.
Unique Pie Offerings
La Renaissance Pâtisserie Française
Nestled in Scarsdale, La Renaissance Pâtisserie Française reinvents apple pie with their fancy apple tarte Tatin, reshaping it into a little slice of heaven. Plus, they’ve got a whole lineup of fruit tarts and morning pastries fresh from the oven. This bakery is where French culinary flair cozies up with local tastes.
If you’re all about that exceptional taste and want something different, La Renaissance is your go-to. Conveniently parked in Scarsdale, it’s a sweet stop for those savoring Westchester’s foodie treasures. For a list of can’t-miss bakeries, scope out our article on the best bakery in Westchester.
| Offering | What’s the Deal |
|---|---|
| Apple Tarte Tatin | French makeover of classic apple pie |
| Fruit Tarts | Fresh fruity fun |
| Breakfast Pastries | Morning goodness, baked just right |
Noble Pies
With spots in Beacon, Rye, Tarrytown, and Warwick, Noble Pies shakes things up with pies that change weekly. From sweet bites like Hudson Valley apple and “Will You Marry Me” cherry pies to savory fixes like chicken pot pies and buffalo chicken pies (Hudson Valley Magazine), they keep it interesting every time you walk through their doors.
If variety and bold flavors tickle your taste buds, Noble Pies is like a playground for your palate. With multiple locations, grabbing a slice of yum is never out of reach.
| Offering | What’s Inside |
|---|---|
| Hudson Valley Apple Pie | Your classic apple pie happiness |
| “Will You Marry Me” Cherry | A cherry pie worth proposing over |
| Chicken Pot Pie | A hearty pie filled with chicken goodness |
| Buffalo Chicken Pie | Spice it up with buffalo chicken pie |
Pieconic NY
Out in Chatham, Pieconic NY is whipping up pies with the freshest goodies. Famous pies like the Empire State bourbon chocolate, Poetic pumpkin, Backyard apple, and Crown Maple pecan have folks buzzing. The Empire State bourbon chocolate pie even graced the screen on NBC’s TODAY Show (Hudson Valley Magazine). At Pieconic NY, there’s a slice for every pie-lover, mixing regional flavors with out-of-this-world recipes.
When you’re passing through Chatham, dropping by Pieconic NY is a no-brainer. The pies are not just tasty—they’re a piece of Westchester’s pie history.
| Offering | What’s in the Crust |
|---|---|
| Empire State Bourbon Chocolate | As seen on NBC, chocolate pie bliss |
| Poetic Pumpkin | Fall flavors packed in a pie |
| Backyard Apple | A timeless apple pie sensation |
| Crown Maple Pecan | A gooey pecan pie with a maple twist |
These pie gems just scratch the surface of Westchester’s food scene. Hungry for more? Dive into our guides on the best places to eat in Westchester and the best food in Westchester.
Local Foodie Events
You’re in for a treat if you’re hunting down the tastiest bites Westchester has to offer. Foodie events here not only serve up a smorgasbord of flavors but also let you explore a variety of scrumptious pies and other gourmet goodies. Let’s dive into some events that should totally be on your radar.
Wine & Food Festival
Get ready to loosen your belt at Westchester Magazine’s Wine & Food Festival in June. This isn’t your average get-together; it’s a blowout that goes on for days. Imagine endless tastings of wine, food, beer, and spirits all under one roof. Here’s a sneak peek of what you’ll find:
- Perfect Pairings of Wine & Food
- Party on the Pier
- Burger & Beer Blast
- Wine Collectors’ Dinner
- Grand Tasting Village
- Bubbly Brunch & Beats
It’s like Disneyland for food lovers, highlighting culinary masterpieces, including Westchester’s legendary pies. Come hungry and leave oh-so-satisfied.
Rosé in Rye Festivities
Put your pinkies up for National Rosé Day in June, celebrated with style at Barley Beach House. It’s all about Rosé with a splash of beachy vibes. Don’t miss out on:
- Endless pours of Rosé cocktails
- Epic charcuterie spreads
- Overflowing chocolate fountains
- An Island Buffet that’ll have you coming back for seconds
- Tunes that’ll make you move
You even get a nifty “Rosé All Day” wine tumbler to remember the fun. The food, including some killer pies, and the festive scene make it a can’t-miss for all sorts of food fans.
Dining Experiences & Tastings
Throughout Westchester, you’ll discover events that transform eating into an adventure. Like the Father’s Day Special: BourbonBaconBeer at Barley Beach House, where you can indulge with:
- Over 25 varieties of bourbon
- A selection of 25 craft beers
- Bacon in ways you’ve never dreamt
- Activities for the kiddos
- Vendors selling all kinds of dad-approved gifts
These aren’t just meals; they’re celebrations packed with flavor, culture, and yes, more of those mouth-watering pies you love.
To keep those taste buds entertained, explore other top-notch spots to dine in Westchester by browsing through different guides and listings.
