Your Guide to the Finest: Best Ice Cream in Westchester
Ice Cream Delights in Westchester
Unforgettable Flavors and Experiences
Westchester’s got the scoop on ice cream that’ll tickle your taste buds. Whether you’re chasing award-winning flavors or creative twists, each shop’s a trip to frozen-dessert heaven.
Stewart’s Shops, a hometown hero, nabbed the top spot for their Philly Vanilla and came in second for chocolate at the 2024 New York State Fair (Stewart’s Shops). Swing by Village Creamery & Sweet Shop in Valhalla for zany mixes like Cookie Monster Meets Peanut Butter Cup or the classic Bananas Foster. These hotspots promise ice cream joints you won’t soon forget.
Local Favorites and Specialties
Westchester boasts a grab-bag of local gems, each dishing out ice cream with its own personality.
Gelato fans, head to La Fenice in Rye, where organic gelato is the star. Made with top-notch organic milk, flavors range from pistachio and gianduia to American classics like salted caramel and mint chip.
Want more? Check out the Ice Cream Factory in Mount Vernon. With 60 flavors daily, including Caribbean-inspired ones like Grapenutt and Jamaican rum raisin, they also offer sugar-free and soy-based options complete with fresh fruit toppings.
For something nostalgic yet modern, Mamaroneck’s Milk N Cookies churns out cereal-milk soft serve with breakfast-themed names like Fruity Pebbles and Cap’n Crunch.
Stopping by these spots will treat you to a flavorful journey through the vibrant mix of Westchester’s cultures. If you fancy yourself a food lover, put these on your must-visit list and dive deeper into the local flavors. Need more bites to try? Peek at the best bakeries in Westchester and top brunch spots around.
Top Ice Cream Spots
Stewart’s Shops: Award-Winning Creations
Stewart’s Shops, nestled in Westchester, is your go-to for ice cream that knocks your socks off. Back in 2024, they bagged the top spot for Best Mint Ice Cream at the World Dairy Expo in Wisconsin. And just to be extra impressive, their Mint Cookie Crumble Ice Cream grabbed a 1st place trophy at the same event. Seems they’ve cracked the code to making taste buds dance.
| Ice Cream Flavor | Award | Event |
|---|---|---|
| Mint Ice Cream | 1st Place | World Dairy Expo 2024 |
| Mint Cookie Crumble Ice Cream | 1st Place | World Dairy Expo 2024 |
Wandering through Westchester with an ice cream itch? Stewart’s is your stop. Dive into their flavor bonanza and savor some award-winning ice cream magic.
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams: Global Acclaim
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams is like that band you knew before everyone else did—now watched and loved worldwide for whipping up what might be the best ice cream there is. They play around with funky flavors (but like, in a good way) and the finest ingredients. Their strive for perfection makes them the Beyoncé of the ice cream world (Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams).
Jeni’s parade of flavors is like a love song to ice cream. Whether you’re old school with flavors like vanilla or the adventurous type craving something out of the ordinary, Jeni’s promises a lick of unforgettable satisfaction.
La Fenice in Rye: Organic Gelato Marvels
Gelato dreamers, head over to La Fenice in Rye. Their gelato isn’t just served, it’s an experience crafted with nature’s best ingredients. This organic bliss comes straight from the rich traditions of Italy, touched up with a modern twist. It’s small batch, but big on flavor.
La Fenice is the sweetheart locale for anyone in or around Westchester with a gelato craving. Their passion for the planet and what they put in their creations makes them a standout choice for a chilly indulgence.
Craving more eats in the area? Check out our guides to best restaurants in Westchester and best brunch in Westchester. Also check out the sweet havens at best bakeries in Westchester.
Picking the best ice cream spot around isn’t just about taste; it’s about those special moments you can only find at places like these. From gold-medal treats to gelato greatness, Westchester’s got your frozen cravings covered. Don’t let these cool spots pass you by.
Unique Offerings
Longford’s Small Batch Ice Cream: Handmade Variety
If you’re in Westchester and scream for ice cream, Longford’s in Rye and Larchmont has you covered. Their small-batch ice cream, lovingly crafted by hand, is legendary—We’re talking over thirty-six flavors that range from nostalgic favorites like Cookie Monster to forward-thinking vegan treats at select spots. It’s a sweet spot worth hitting up if you’re in the mood for an icy adventure in Westchester.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Cookie Monster | Bright blue with crunchy cookie pieces |
| Brookies n’ Cream | Vanilla and chocolate swirl with brownies in the mix |
Love munching on delicious finds? Dive into our guide to the best places to eat around Westchester for more awesome eats.
Village Creamery & Sweet Shop: Artisanal Innovations
Over in Valhalla, the Village Creamery & Sweet Shop is whipping up ice cream dreams come true. All-natural? Check. Creative combos? Double-check! From the tantalizing Cookie Monster Meets Peanut Butter Cup to seasonal delights like mint candy cane, they’ve got it all. Dive headfirst into their flavors for a joyous ride of savory and sweet.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Cookie Monster Meets Peanut Butter Cup | Peanut butter swirl and cookie crumbles united |
| Let’s Do Brunch | Maple magic with bacon and French toast bits |
Peckish for local flavor? Our top restaurant roundup in Westchester is just the ticket.
Paleteria Fernandez: Fruity & Dairy-Free Delights
For a fruit-filled fiesta or a dairy-free delight, Paleteria Fernandez is the spot. Based in Port Chester and Mamaroneck, they serve up paleteria-style treats and paletas. With over 40 mostly dairy-free delights, from hibiscus to spicy chili-mango, you won’t go wrong. Satisfy your taste buds with Chamango slushies or an ice-cold milkshake, bursting with popsicle flavors.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Hibiscus | Light, floral, and oh-so refreshing |
| Spicy Chili-Mango | Sweet mango with a sassy chili kick |
Seeking dairy-free dessert awesomeness? Paleteria Fernandez tops the best dessert spots around Westchester list.
Ice Cream Factory: Caribbean Flavors Extravaganza
Mount Vernon’s Ice Cream Factory spins out daily surprises—over 60 flavors, including Caribbean classics like Grapenutt and Jamaican rum raisin. Sugar-free and soy-based picks are on the menu too, perfect with fresh fruit or sweet toppings. Stop by and let your tastebuds take a tropical vacation.
| Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Grapenutt | A bold blend where grape meets nutty notes |
| Jamaican Rum Raisin | An island getaway of rum flavor with raisins |
Looking for more chow-chow tips on Westchester’s food scene? Peek at our blogs on the best breakfast, best brunch, and best lunch spots around.
Sweet Treats and Tasty Stops
Hunting for the tastiest ice cream in Westchester? You’ve come to the right place. These local spots are known for their fun flavors and top-notch selections that’ll satisfy any sweet tooth.
Main Street Sweets: Ice Cream Heaven
Over in Tarrytown, Main Street Sweets dishes out 30 out-of-this-world ice cream flavors every day. Dive into the Main Street Special or Devon’s Dream. If you’re on a vegan diet, don’t fret! There’s coconut milk matcha or chocolate to satisfy those cravings. They’ve even got waffle cones that are as exciting as the ice cream they hold—think red velvet and birthday cake.
| Ice Cream Flavor | Description |
|---|---|
| Main Street Special | Packed with mixed-in surprises |
| Devon’s Dream | Creamy goodness that fans love |
| Coconut Milk Matcha | Vegan twist with a matcha punch |
| Chocolate | Vegan take on the classic fave |
Milk N Cookies: Cereal-Milk Bliss
Milk N Cookies turns breakfast into dessert with their cereal-milk soft serve. It’s basically a trip down memory lane—perfect for reliving those childhood cereal mornings.
Here’s what you’ll find:
- Customizable Cereal-Milk Soft Serve
- Fun cones like chocolate-dipped or sprinkles galore
- Unique milk flares and milkshakes
Muji Food Market: Taste of Japan
New York City’s Muji Food Market brings Japanese flair to Westchester with their inventive desserts. Try a Floral Blossom Yuzu Matcha Refresher, Iced Matcha Strawberry Latte, or snack on Karaage Onigiri and Matcha Dorayaki.
| Treat | What’s Inside |
|---|---|
| Floral Blossom Yuzu Matcha Refresher | Drink with floral vibes |
| Iced Matcha Strawberry Latte | Chilled matcha with strawberry |
| Karaage Onigiri | Rice ball with crispy chicken |
| Matcha Dorayaki | Pancake treat with matcha filling |
Ice Cream Social: A Sweet Party Menu
Ice Cream Social is all about variety. With a lineup of handmade ice creams and sorbets, you’re set for classic or daring flavors. It’s your ice cream; go wild!
Here’s what’s scoopin’:
- Artisan-style ice creams with local flair
- Flavors that change with the seasons
- Toppings and mix-ins for custom sundaes
Complete your sweet fix by exploring best dining options to pair with these treats.
Looking for more food fun? Check out:
- best lunch spots in westchester
- best brunch in westchester
- best dessert in westchester
Get ready to dig into these yummy ice cream delights and make your Westchester adventure super sweet.