Exceptional Fare: Ranking the Best Delis in Westchester
Delis in Westchester County
Taking a bite out of the delis in Westchester is like diving into a foodie wonderland where rich flavors and traditions meet joy. Let’s dive into the treasure trove of delis you’ll find and how they keep things spot-on with safety and quality.
Best Delis in Westchester County
Checking out the top delis around? It’s like unwrapping gifts where every bite has a story to tell. Yelp’s got a rundown of the top 10 delis that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance.
| Rank | Deli Name | City | Yelp Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jerry’s Post Road Market | Scarsdale | 4.5 |
| 2 | Tarry Market | Port Chester | 4.5 |
| 3 | Dante’s Gourmet Deli | White Plains | 4.5 |
| 4 | Fine Choice Delicatessen | Bronxville | 4.4 |
| 5 | Mike’s Deli | Bronx | 4.4 |
| 6 | The Rye Corner | Rye | 4.4 |
| 7 | Goldie’s Delicatessen | Mount Kisco | 4.4 |
| 8 | A&S Pork Store | Mamaroneck | 4.3 |
| 9 | Belizio Brothers | New Rochelle | 4.3 |
| 10 | Villa Rustica | Elmsford | 4.3 |
From sandwiches that make your heart sing to salads that are a guilty pleasure, these places are the real deal. Want to explore more yummies? Swing by our top eats in Westchester page for more delish spots.
Deli Regulations in Westchester County
Running a deli ain’t just about feeding people. It’s about doing it right by playing by some important rules to keep everyone safe and sound. Here’s how:
- Calorie Info: If you’re running a chain, showing those calorie counts is a must. This little nugget of info guides folks to eating smarter (Westchester County Government).
- Allergy Alerts: Imagine bites free of pesky surprises. Menus must shout out allergy alerts so everyone knows to give staff a heads-up about their no-go foods.
- Food Safety 101: It’s gotta be fresh, tasty, and safe. So, food safety rules cover storage, cleanliness, and handling, with regular check-ins to stay on track.
Making sure delis play by these rules means everyone’s noshing happily without a hitch. Craving more foodie finds? Peek at our pages on best bagels in Westchester and best brunch in Westchester for more spots to munch.
Arthur Avenue Deli Experience
Market Highlights on Arthur Avenue
Right in the heart of the Bronx, Arthur Avenue is an eating paradise bursting with flavor and history. Sure, some old favorites like Danny’s Pork Store have left us, but plenty of joints are still there keeping that Italian culinary heritage alive. The hustle and bustle of these markets make them a special spot, dishing up some of what folks call the best food in Westchester.
| Market | Highlights |
|---|---|
| Arthur Avenue Retail Market | Got an ace butcher at Peter’s, the king of Italian combos at Greco’s, and Café el Mercato for pizza that leaves you wanting more. Serious Eats |
| Vincent’s & Biancardi’s | These guys know their stuff, making pancetta and some killer house-cured prosciutto. Serious Eats |
| Casa della Mozarella | Got the freshest mozzarella in the city, plus goodies like provolone, scamorza, and bocconcini. Serious Eats |
| Borgatti’s | Expert in all things pasta, serving ravioli, manicotti, and egg noodles, all just how you like ‘em. Serious Eats |
Must-Try Foods on Arthur Avenue
Arthur Avenue serves up dishes with such authenticity that once you try them, you’ll be hooked. These eats perfectly capture the spirit of Italian cooking, and they’re a feast for your taste buds.
Italian Combo at Greco’s
Whether you knew it as Mike’s or Greco’s, this sandwich haven in the Arthur Avenue Retail Market crafts the tastiest Italian combo in the Bronx, beloved by locals who recognize quality.
House-Cured Prosciutto from Vincent’s and Biancardi’s
Vincent’s and Biancardi’s are famous for their house-cured prosciutto. Their pancetta with a hit of Calabrian chili is like art on a plate. No kidding.
Mozzarella from Casa della Mozarella
This place is the mozzarella master, serving the freshest in town. Sample their provolone, scamorza, and bocconcini—all crowd-pleasers.
Fresh Pasta from Borgatti’s
Borgatti’s has been perfecting pasta for 70 years. Offering ravioli, manicotti, and egg noodles, made exactly how you like them, it’s a pasta lover’s dream.
Arthur Avenue is a deli wonderland where each shop has something special brewing. For more vibes on the best places to eat in Westchester, stick Arthur Avenue on your foodie bucket list.
Crafting a Deli Menu
Crafting a killer deli menu involves mixing classic crowd-pleasers with fresh, new ideas, making sure you’ve got something for everyone while carving out a bit of flair that sets you apart. Let’s dive into the basics of building a deli menu and some tips to keep it fresh and exciting.
Essentials of a Deli Menu
When you’re putting together a deli menu, there are a few must-haves people expect. According to Toast Blog, these essentials generally include:
- Sandwiches – The staples of any deli menu. Classic options like Reubens, pastrami wonders, and good old corned beef are non-negotiable.
- Soups – Comforting bowls like matzo ball, chicken noodle, and clam chowder are delights people keep coming back for.
- Salads – Fresh, build-your-own style salads give a nod to the health-conscious crowd.
Tips for Deli Menu Innovation
Keeping things fresh and exciting on your deli menu is crucial if you want people to keep coming back. Here’s how you can spice things up:
Master the Basics
Start with nailing those classic deli delights. Nobody comes back for sloppy sandwiches. Keep quality high – your bread, your fillings, your condiments – it’s all gotta be top-notch.
Explore Modifiers and Add-Ons
Extra toppings or sides can make meals extra special and help increase what customers spend. Encourage folks to tweak their sandwiches and salads with different toppings and spreads to give each order a personal touch.
Track Your Costs
Being creative is fun, but you also gotta make a buck. Keep an eye on what those ingredients are costing you and price your menu smartly. A nice mix of budget-friendly eats and a few splurge items can keep your menu both attractive and profitable (Toast Blog).
Local Inspiration
Bring some local flavors into your menu. It’s a good way to connect with folks around you. Try out new starters and mains as specials to see what customers love before making them permanent. Chit-chat with local farmers and suppliers to keep your ingredients fresh and give your dishes some local charm.
For a dose of local flavor inspiration, check out the best restaurants in Westchester or the best places to eat in Westchester to see what’s getting people excited.
Competitive Pricing
Folks want tasty food without breaking the bank. Make sure your items are priced well and people feel like they’re getting a swell deal. This isn’t about being the cheapest, but about offering true value (Toast Blog).
| Go-To Items | Features | Why It’s On the Menu |
|---|---|---|
| Sandwiches | Traditional, mix-and-match fillings | Bread and butter of your deli |
| Soups | Classic comfort varieties | Pairs perfectly with sandwiches |
| Salads | Fresh, customizable | A lighter option for variety |
Using these tips can help you offer a lively and tempting menu, helping your deli stand out among the best delis in Westchester. Balancing tried-and-true favorites with fresh ideas ensures your customers stay pumped and keep coming back for more.
Popular Deli Menu Items
Checking out what delis are cooking up is basically a rite of passage to understand the best delis in Westchester. These spots are serving up some iconic eats, bringing together folks of all flavors. From the Reuben sandwich to pastrami treats, classic corned beef vibes, and those legendary deli soups—you’ve got plenty of reasons to munch.
The Reuben Sandwich
The Reuben sandwich is the hero of deli menus, thanks to its killer mix of flavors and textures. Stack up some corned beef, Swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing between rye bread slices, and you’ve got a meal that’s perfect for anytime munching. The balance of tangy sauerkraut, creamy dressing, and savory corned beef just hits differently.
Now, there are some fun twists on the classic:
| Variation | Description |
|---|---|
| Traditional Reuben | Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on rye |
| Turkey Reuben | Lighter, switches corned beef for turkey |
| Veggie Reuben | For the veggie lovers, with grilled veggies instead |
| Reuben Burger | Beef it up with a burger and all the Reuben goodness |
Craving more sandwiches? Swing by the best sandwiches in Westchester.
Pastrami Specialties
Pastrami on rye is another fan favorite, with its smoky, spiced slices meeting the heartiness of rye bread. Juicy and flavorful, it’s a go-to for anyone after a big, tasty bite to eat.
| Variation | Description |
|---|---|
| Traditional Pastrami | Delicate slices of pastrami on rye bread |
| Grilled Pastrami Sandwich | Add some crunch by hitting the grill |
| Pastrami Reuben | Swap out corned beef for pastrami in a Reuben |
| Pastrami Burger | A burger’s best friend with pastrami on top |
Delis are shaking things up with creations like Pastrami Fries for the adventurous munchers. Check out more at the best diners in Westchester.
Classic Corned Beef Options
Ah, corned beef sandwiches—bringing that classic deli feel. The simple yet high-quality Corned Beef on Rye is always a winner, a nostalgic nod to tasty times.
| Variation | Description |
|---|---|
| Classic Corned Beef | Corned beef on rye bread |
| Corned Beef Reuben | Amp it up with sauerkraut and Russian dressing |
| Hot Corned Beef Sandwich | Cozy and warming with every mouthful |
Whether you’re grabbing to go or sitting down, these choices never let you down. For more spots that do it right, look at the best places to eat in Westchester.
Iconic Deli Soups
Comfort food alert—Matzo Ball Soup’s where it’s at for those soothing, warm-me-up moments. Picture fluffy matzo balls floating in a golden chicken broth—talk about a classic cure when feeling under the weather.
| Soup Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Matzo Ball Soup | Those matzo balls snuggled in chicken broth |
| Mushroom Barley Soup | Mushrooms and barley team up for a hearty bowl |
| Chicken Orzo Soup | Light, tasty chicken broth meets orzo pasta |
These soups often steal the show on deli menus. Need more soup suggestions? Dive into the best lunch spots in Westchester.
Tasting these deli classics gives you a real taste of Westchester’s best delis. So, grab a fork, or just dive in with your hands, and explore the rich flavors and comforting dishes delis have been serving up for ages.