Home Economic Development Mayor pushes for cleanup of Mount Vernon’s ‘Big Stink’ on the...

Mayor pushes for cleanup of Mount Vernon’s ‘Big Stink’ on the Hutchinson River

mount vernon big stink revitalization mayor richard thomas
Mount Vernon Mayor Richard Thomas at the city’s public works recycling center along the Eastchester Creek, also known as the Hutchinson River. He is pushing for a cleanup of the area and waterway for redevelopment as a waterfront dining and recreational destination. Photo by Bill Heltzel

An impending federal lawsuit could become the impetus for converting the dirty, stinky, silted, noxious, underused waterfront along Eastchester Creek in Mount Vernon into a recreation and dining destination.

Or at least that’s the theory.

For 14 years, Mount Vernon has ignored federal Environmental Protection Agency consent decrees, according to Mayor Richard Thomas, and now the U.S. Department of Justice is about to sue the city for violations of the Clean Water Act.

Thomas wants to use the threat of federal sanctions to compel every elected city official to commit to cleaning up the waterfront.

Doing so, he said, would convert a liability into an asset and stimulate economic development. The city’s public works salt storage and recycling center, for instance, could be transformed into a waterpark and sports complex.

Waterfront cleanup is part of the Canal Village Revitalization Plan, a broader initiative that has been underway for several years. The city has received two state grants to create a master plan for redeveloping 241 acres in its heavily industrialized southeast section. The master plan would enable the city to pay for improvements with state and federal development grants.

mount vernon big stink eastchester creek revitalization
A potential boat launch on the waterway. Photo by Bill Heltzel

Thomas is focused on a few acres at the public works facility and the adjacent Sprague Operating Resources petroleum tank farm.

He refers to this location as “the Port of Mount Vernon.” The narrow creek, also called the Hutchinson River, flows into Eastchester Bay and Long Island Sound. About 700,000 tons of materials — petroleum, sand and gravel, rock salt, scrap metal — are transported upriver to docks in Mount Vernon. The channel has become so clogged with silt that tugs and barges can navigate only at high tide.

mount vernon eastchester creek
A tank farm along the waterway. Photo by Bill Heltzel

Next month, Sprague will begin dredging 12,500 cubic yards of material and carving out a nine-foot-deep pathway. The project will cost $2 million, Thomas said, and the city will pay half.

He wants to spend another $4 million cleaning up the public works yard, or as he puts it, “getting stuff off the waterfront.”

A lot of the stuff is recycling materials that are stored in roll-off receptacles and yard wastes that are piled all over the place. The city pays a carting company $280,000 a year to move the stuff about 150 yards to a county waste transfer station.

Tons of salt used by several towns are stored in a rickety wooden structure next to the creek, where rain easily washes sodium into the waterway.

“This is just sloppy,” Thomas said, waving his arms at the stuff spread out indiscriminately near the creek. “We don’t need this much space for this much material.”

He said everything now contained on 20 acres can be consolidated on two acres. Salt mounds would be moved to a suitable structure closer to the public works garage. Recycling operations would be placed next to the waste transfer station. Public works and the Sprague facility would be walled off with fences and greenery.

The mayor thinks the work could be done in two years. Then the emptied space would be available for development.

Thomas is proposing a water park, including a swimming pool, bath house, sandy beach, boat launch and restaurants.

“I don’t anticipate people swimming in the Hutch, yet,” he said. “But I can see them eating here and swimming in a pool and kayaking and boating and fishing.”

The Sports Underdome, the Ice Hutch, Glover Field and Memorial Field are lined up parallel to the creek. Thomas would like to expand the athletic facilities in a Chelsea Piers-like glass and steel and concrete structure.

Between the creek and athletic fields, you can barely make out the trailhead of an overgrown path that hugs the waterway up to Willson’s Woods Park. Trail access is blocked by the public works operations. If that were opened up and the land were reclaimed, Thomas said, “You would see joggers all the way up to Eastchester.”

The creek also is rather odoriferous. One participant at a recent Canal Village public workshop referred to it as the “Big Stink.”

The brackish water is a grayish-green indicative of sewage. And sure enough, raw sewage is being dumped into the creek upstream at the Farrell Avenue outfall.

Which goes back to that impending federal Clean Water Act lawsuit. The feds want the city to fix broken sewers to keep sewage from seeping into the Long Island Sound and its tributaries.

That work, the mayor said, could take 10 years and cost millions of dollars. “When it’s cleaned up,” he said, “the stench goes away.”

It can be done, he said. Just remember how dirty the Hudson River was and how much progress has been made on the Gowanus Canal in Brooklyn.

Thomas pointed across the creek to well-groomed athletic fields in Pelham Manor.

“Look at how they value the waterfront,” he said.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email


  1. I am an industrial RE broker for over 25 years who has sold and leased much of the properties along the Eastchester Creek. Every past Planner at Mount Vernon in this period would truthfully explain the idea of Canal Village, the reports or studies about it, are only entertained because they are paid for free by the state. The huge tax dollars generated to Mount Vernon by keeping these properties as high value industrial is much, much greater than the tax income of
    any type of retail including any sales tax that would generate. Especially not the low demand, low sales dollar, leisure type uses he espouses.

    Basically, the land is worth 3-5 x more as existing industrial property than the light commercial he espouses. Mt Vernon depends on these huge current values for property tax income.

    My statements are proven when looking at what happened to Pelham Manor across the creek so unfairly changed their industrial zone to retail in the late 90’s and thus lowered the values by about 75%. Retail here is worth much less than half of Industrial and not in demand. See the 15 mostly vacant acres for the last 15 years along the Pelham Manor side of the creek and how it had traded for 25% of industrial values. With no retailers having bitten on such a rare, large vacant site, Pelham Manor has finally in the last few years allowed industrial to come back for the higher taxes they now get from use licenses.

    The Sprague terminal is of National importance by the way- see hurricanes and heating oil gas station supply issues. You hurt Sprague’s operation if developing retail around it.

    Taking that industrial area away would continue the great rise in costs for everyone who lives in our area. It is where we get our fuel oil, bus parking, construction lots and asphalt plants and other necessary industrial space. Not to mention our good jobs. Some environmental issues are there but not being created there any longer. Nor are they too serious. The DEC has not been pushing any of the property owners to do anything since the more serious problems are seemingly still flowing down into it from farther north, the Sandford Boulevard area and not from any of the current industrial users.

    The stink by the way is probably not from any pollution but from the seawater and naturally occurring with the rise and fall of the tide. Ever drive down the hutch with your windows down around Pelham Bay?

    The real question is why would the Mayor promote this idea when he must know it is hurtful to Mount Vernon? It only scares industry and blunts the continued increase in property value and property taxes the city depends upon.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here